Project Credits
Content Standards
The WebQuest Page
Dolly “Researchers Astounded ... Fiction Becomes True and Dreaded Possibilities Are Raised."* Some 60 years ago amphibians were used to produce clones, but the embryos died at tadpole stage. During the last six decades, the cloning of a mammal was only possible in the imagination of the scientific community.
Hello Dolly! Out of the blue, researchers from the Roslin Institute announced that they had successfully cloned a lamb. The next day, the Pope denounced the discovery as a "lack of respect for life". The scientific community hailed the discovery as a break through for mankind. Your task will be to analyze the differing perspectives, and draw your own conclusion about the social, economic and political effects of cloning on individuals, families and communities. You will be assessed on how you support your conclusion, communicate effectively, and collaborate with your peers.
The honorable Mr. Ehlers a United States House Of Representatives member from the grand state of Michigan has proposed the following legislation:

FILE h923.ih
HR 923 IH
105th CONGRESS
1st Session


To prohibit the cloning of humans.
IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
March 5, 1997
Mr. EHLERS introduced the following bill; which was referred to the
Committee on Commerce
A BILL
To prohibit the cloning of humans.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of
Representatives of the United States of America in Congress
assembled,
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the `Human Cloning Prohibition Act'.
SEC. 2. PROHIBITION AGAINST CLONING OF HUMANS.
(a) IN GENERAL- It shall be unlawful for any person to use a
human somatic cell for the process of producing a human clone.
(b) CIVIL MONEY PENALTY- Any person who violates subsection (a)
is liable to the United States for a civil money penalty in an
amount not exceeding $5,000.

cell
The United States House Of Representatives is assembling a group of specialists to investigate the wide spread implications of cloning on the social, economic, and political fabric of American society. Each specialist will present their findings to a special sub-committee. It will be the responsibility of the sub-committee members to not only evaluate the "Human Coning Prohibition Act", but they must also determine if the bill should be expanded in include other types of cloning.
Main Concept Each classroom team will be assigned a role. To make sure your team members fully understand their roles, open the dossiers below to learn about each groups responsibilities.

US Department of Agriculture

An expert scientific team that will focus on the benefit of cloning on the nation's food supply.
Friends of Animals A nationally recognized group of citizens that promote the human treatment of animals.
Professors of Biomedical Ethics A few of the nations top scholars of biomedical ethics.
CLN Pharmaceutical A company committed to the advancement of pharmaceutical products using cloning. A main contributor to the original Dolly cloning experiment.
Clone Tech A San Diego bio-tech firm that currently has several cloning patents involving cloning of human body parts.
Roslin Institute Team A group of devoted scientists that cloned a sheep: Dolly. Their role will be to explain cloning.
Institute of Theology and Ethic An international group of theologians of various ideologies.
U.S. Senate Sub-committee A group of distinguished senators gathered together to analyze the "Human Cloning Prohibition Act".
Brainstorm Open the dossier for your role by clicking on the appropriate role above. Read the contents of the dossier to get a feel for your tasks. Analyze how your role relates to the other members on the panel.

Brainstorm a list of the types of resources/information that you think would be useful to gain your insights on cloning.

Explore the "Resources" below (as well as any available at headquarters - i.e., the Library) to see which might match with your brainstormed list.

Note the name of the internet/classroom resources next to your brainstormed list.

 

Assign group tasks Each member in the group must be responsible for more than one task. Review the tasks below and determine who will be responsible for the task.
Team Leader will be the main contact for the teacher
Internet Research Team will find artifacts on the internet. It is helpful if these students have access to the internet at home.
Library Research Team will search through newspapers, journals and texts for artifacts.
Writing Team will do all the writing for the team. Access to a word-processing program at home is a good idea.
Presentation Engineer will learn Power Point or construct posters, overheads and lecture notes.
Presenters will present the team's findings to the senate sub-committee.
Cyberspace Investigation Hints Explore the resources that you think would be most appropriate for your branch. Collect (Copy & Paste) the five artifacts (picture or text) that you think represent the topic you are exploring. Remember to keep track of the URL (the code that appears in the "Location" line in the browser) For each artifact, make sure you know why you believe it is a good example for the topic. Fill out the synopsis form. Once you have finished your search, choose the best artifacts for your topic.
Group Consensus As a team, you must discuss, persuade, argue, deal, and brainstorm an plan of attack. You will not all agree on the best way to present your research to the senate sub-committee, but you must reach a consensus. You must agree to disagree, and find the best solution.

 

Your Special Report It is your job to argue your perspective effectively. If you choose to do a Power Point presentation, it is your responsibility to make sure the program will work before the day of the special sub-committee reports. If you are not using Power Point, you may create a butcher paper mural, or you may choose to create a video project. Be creative.
Websites The Roslin Institute Online CNN Interactive: Scientists grow monkeys The Nature Homepage

Poll: Most Americans say cloning is wrong

Interview with cloner

New Scientist Homepage

Eternity Online Magazine

The truth behind DNA

How a sheep was cloned

NATIONAL BIO-ETHICS ADVISORY COMMISSION

Farm Bureau

Exploratorium: The Cloning Question

USA Today: Cloning for healthier humans

Library Microsoft Word list of available library resources.
email With the help of Stratagene, students will interact with experts through email. Our contact at Stratagene is Judi Heitz. Thank you Stratagene!
Should the Human Cloning Prohibition Act be expanded to all aspects of cloning? Will the scientific community act responsibly? Is a $5,000 fine enough to deter people from cloning humans? Good Luck! Work smart! and Ask good questions!

Hello Dolly is a webquest project that requires students to ask good questions, access current information, analyze the validity of sources, apply new knowledge to evaluate a current controversy, and reach consensus with peers.

For more information about "Hello Dolly", please contact Keith Nuthall.
Quote taken from the New York Times. Issue date unknown.

Return to Dolly main page
Return to Senate main page